Maui Vacation Rentals vs. Resorts
Choosing a Maui vacation rental over a resort means more space, fewer fees, and greater flexibility all while enjoying a home-like experience in paradise.
All of the photos in this article share Polo Beach Club #707. Call (808) 879-6284 for availability and the best price.
Cost Savings
In June 2023, Maui hotels averaged $606 per night with 74% occupancy, while vacation rentals averaged $352 per night with 67% occupancy. You’ll find better prices and more options with a vacation rental.
Unlike hotels, rentals lack resort fees ($25–$50 per night), often include free parking, and have free Wi-Fi. With a full kitchen, guests can save thousands by avoiding restaurant meals. A family of four dining out spends over $2,000 per week, while cooking at home slashes costs.
Many rentals also come with in-unit laundry, reducing the need for overpacking or costly hotel laundry services. Larger groups benefit even more, splitting the cost of a spacious home instead of booking multiple hotel rooms. Many rentals offer weekly or monthly discounts, making them ideal for extended stays.
Comfort & Amenities
Hotels average 300–400 sq. ft. per room, while rentals range from spacious condos to private homes over 2,000 sq. ft. Guests enjoy multiple bedrooms, full kitchens, living spaces, and lanais, creating a more relaxing stay.
Private pools, hot tubs, and beach gear (chairs, snorkels, coolers) are often included, saving rental fees. In-unit laundry lets travelers pack light. Unlike resorts with crowded pools and lobbies, rentals provide increased privacy.
Flexibility & Convenience
Rentals offer more location options, from beachfront cottages to Upcountry escapes. Guests set their own schedule, avoiding rigid hotel dining hours and housekeeping interruptions.
Many rentals feature self check-in, eliminating long lobby waits. No valet lines or parking fees mean quick, hassle-free access. Rentals in residential areas put visitors near local markets, restaurants, and hidden gems, offering a more authentic Maui experience.
